15
$\begingroup$

Update 3

I've worked out a solution that is bearable for a small number of subregions in the neighbour and added it as an answer. I'm going to make a post for optimisation help.


Update 2

For a second attempt I have tried a geometric computation approach using RegionIntersection and the GeoBoundingBox of the entities.

geoBorderingEntities2[region_, entities_List?VectorQ] :=
 Module[{intersections, positions},
  intersections =
   With[{borderPoly = region["Polygon"] /. {GeoPosition :> Identity}},
    ParallelMap[
     RegionIntersection[
       borderPoly,
       Rectangle @@ (GeoBoundingBox[#] /. {GeoPosition :> 
            Identity})] &,
     entities, 1]
    ];
  positions = 
   Position[intersections, x_ /; ! (Head@x === EmptyRegion), {1}, 
    Heads -> False];
  Extract[entities, positions]]

This also takes some time to execute because of the complexity of the polygons that make up the geo-borders. I'm also not too keen on this approach as there are conditions where an entity's bounding box will intersect but it will not be on the boarder due to the shape of either entities.

bordering = geoBorderingEntities2[ny, adminDivs];
GeoGraphics[{
  {EdgeForm[Black], Yellow, Sequence @@ (Polygon[#] & /@ adminDivs)},
  {Red, ny["Polygon"]},
  {EdgeForm[Black], Black, 
   Tooltip[Polygon[#], #["Name"]] & /@ bordering}}, 
 GeoBackground -> None]

enter image description here

In any case, there are also some items that border that are not selected by this method. Still, it takes too long. I have another idea I'm considering.

Any other ideas out there?


Update 1

I have attempted this (very inefficiently) by trying to match the points of the polygon of the region to those of the subdivision regions with little success.

geoBorderingEntities[region_, entities_List?VectorQ] :=
 Module[{pointMatches, positions},
  pointMatches = ParallelMap[IntersectingQ[
      Partition[
       Flatten@(region["Polygon"] /. {GeoPosition :> Identity, 
           Polygon :> Identity, EntityValue :> Identity}), 2],
      Partition[
       Flatten@(#["Polygon"] /. {GeoPosition :> Identity, 
           Polygon :> Identity, EntityValue :> Identity}), 2]
      ] &, entities, 1];
  positions = Position[pointMatches, True];
  Extract[entities, positions]
  ]

The replacements are needed as the region functions to not play nice with geographic polygons yet (as at version 10.2). In any case this does not work well.

ny = AdministrativeDivisionData[{"NewYork", "UnitedStates"}];
pa = AdministrativeDivisionData[{"Pennsylvania", "UnitedStates"}];
adminDivs = 
  EntityValue[
   Entity["AdministrativeDivision", 
    {EntityProperty["AdministrativeDivision", "ParentRegion"] -> pa}],
   "Entities"];

From the counties for Pennsylvania only 2 result in a match with this method.

bordering = geoBorderingEntities[ny, adminDivs]
(* {Entity["AdministrativeDivision", {"PikeCounty", "Pennsylvania", "UnitedStates"}], 
 Entity["AdministrativeDivision", {"WayneCounty", "Pennsylvania", "UnitedStates"}]} *)

Clearly I should have more matches.

GeoGraphics[
 {{EdgeForm[Black], Yellow, Sequence @@ (Polygon[#] & /@ adminDivs)}, 
  {Red, ny["Polygon"]}, 
  {EdgeForm[Black], Black, Polygon[#] & /@ bordering}}, 
 GeoBackground -> None]

enter image description here

However, in hindsight, it was a stretch to think that points would be shared along bordering geo-entities. They should have lines that touch, though.

I am considering RegionUnion with the entity polygons but am still thinking how I would check that the union has formed a connected region. I might consider a Piecewise parametric equation of the polynomials and if there is a real solution to there intersection. Seems a bit of overkill, though.

Ideas?


Original Post

I would like to get the counties (e.g. second level administrative divisions) that border the Gulf of Mexico. OceanData has the "BorderingCountries" properties that gives the country list.

OceanData["GulfMexico"]["BorderingCountries"]

I'm not certain how to use OceanData and CountryData (or AdministrativeDivisionData) to get to the administrative divisions that border the ocean.

I'd appreciate a nudge in the correct direction. Ideally, I'm looking for (or to create) a method that will work in general for any ocean and counties (i.e. administration division 2) of any country. Also, any higher administrative division to lower neighbouring administrative divisions (e.g. all the Pennsylvania counties bordering New York state).

Ideas?

$\endgroup$
14
$\begingroup$

You can use GeoNearest to find all counties that are distance zero away from something, e.g. a body of water.

Here's the Gulf of Mexico:

border = GeoNearest["USCounty", Entity["Ocean", "GulfMexico"], {All, 0}];

GeoGraphics[{Red, EdgeForm[Black], Polygon[border]}]

enter image description here

$\endgroup$
6
$\begingroup$

I have developed a solution that is bearable. It takes about one second to evaluate each neighbouring subregion in cases that I have tested that have about 60 subregions. This is still far too slow but is the best I have come up with to date.

geoBorderingEntities[region_, entities_List?VectorQ, 
  geoPadding_?QuantityQ] :=
 Module[{borderBox, borderPoly, boxIntersections, intersections, 
   positions, borderPoints},
  borderBox = 
   Rectangle @@ (GeoBoundingBox[region, 
       geoPadding] /. {GeoPosition :> Identity});
  borderPoly = region["Polygon"] /. {GeoPosition :> Identity};
  boxIntersections =
   ParallelMap[
    RegionIntersection[
      borderBox,
      Rectangle @@ (GeoBoundingBox[#, 
          geoPadding] /. {GeoPosition :> Identity})] &,
    entities, 1];
  (* Faster to split them *)
  intersections = ParallelMap[
    Function[{index},
     With[{boxToPoly = 
        Evaluate@
         RegionIntersection[boxIntersections[[index]], borderPoly]},
      If[Head[boxToPoly] === EmptyRegion,
       boxToPoly,
       RegionIntersection[
        boxToPoly, (entities[[index]][
           "Polygon"] /. {GeoPosition :> Identity})]
       ]
      ]
     ],
    Range[Length@entities], {1}];
  positions = 
   Position[intersections, x_ /; ! (Head@x === EmptyRegion), {1}, 
    Heads -> False];
  Extract[entities, positions]]

geoPadding is used to slightly inflate the GeoBoundingBox for neighbouring subregions border on vertical or horizontal line.

ny = AdministrativeDivisionData[{"NewYork", "UnitedStates"}];
pa = AdministrativeDivisionData[{"Pennsylvania", "UnitedStates"}];
adminDivsPa = 
  EntityValue[
   Entity["AdministrativeDivision", {EntityProperty[
       "AdministrativeDivision", "ParentRegion"] -> pa}], "Entities"];

borderingNyPa = geoBorderingEntities[ny, adminDivsPa, Quantity[1, "Kilometers"]];

GeoGraphics[{
   {EdgeForm[Black], Yellow, Sequence @@ (Polygon[#] & /@ adminDivsPa)}, 
   {Red, ny["Polygon"]}, 
   {EdgeForm[Black], Black, Tooltip[Polygon[#], #["Name"]] & /@ borderingNyPa }}, 
 GeoBackground -> None]

enter image description here

I think I will make a post asking for help to optimise it.


wv = AdministrativeDivisionData[{"WestVirginia", "UnitedStates"}];
oh = AdministrativeDivisionData[{"Ohio", "UnitedStates"}];
adminDivsOh = 
  EntityValue[
   Entity["AdministrativeDivision", {EntityProperty[
       "AdministrativeDivision", "ParentRegion"] -> oh}], "Entities"];

borderingWvOh = 
 geoBorderingEntities[wv, adminDivsOh, Quantity[1, "Kilometers"]];

GeoGraphics[{{EdgeForm[Black], Yellow, 
   Sequence @@ (Polygon[#] & /@ adminDivsOh)}, {Red, 
   wv["Polygon"]}, {EdgeForm[Black], Black, 
   Tooltip[Polygon[#], #["Name"]] & /@ borderingWvOh}}, 
 GeoBackground -> None]

enter image description here

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

After we discussed RegionMember today, decided to give it another try. Seems to work pretty well.

poly[geoPol_] := geoPol /. GeoPosition :> Identity
vert[geoPol_] := Part[poly[geoPol], 1]

borderingDivision[refGeoEntity_, potGeoEntities_] := 
 Module[{polygon, vertices}, polygon = poly[refGeoEntity["Polygon"]]; 
  vertices = vert[#] & /@ EntityValue[potGeoEntities, "Polygon"]; 
  Extract[potGeoEntities, 
   Position[
    Table[Or @@ RegionMember[polygon, #] & @@ vertices[[n]], {n, 
      Length@vertices}], True]]]

validStates= borderingDivision[OceanData["GulfMexico"],CountryData["UnitedStates"]["AdministrativeDivisions"]]
(*Alabama,Florida,Louisiana,Mississippi, Texas*)

counties = Flatten@EntityValue[validStates, "Subdivisions"];

borderingCounties=borderingDivision[OceanData["GulfMexico"], counties];

GeoGraphics[{Red, EdgeForm[Black], Polygon[borderingCounties]}]

enter image description here

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ This works for the Gulf of Mexico case but does not work in the general case. Take the New York state and Pennsylvania counties case above. I think the Gulf's boarders overlay into the counties which is why this works. Still, very fast but not complete enough. $\endgroup$ – Edmund Oct 19 '15 at 19:02
4
$\begingroup$

Here's another solution Edmund and I worked on today. The one draw back to this solution is it potentially requires a lot of data to download.

BorderingGeoEntities[cands_List, hub_, threshold_:0.0012] := 
 Module[{polygons, dhub, df, dists},
  polygons = EntityValue[cands, "Polygon"];
  dhub = DiscretizeGraphics[Graphics[Line /@ hub["Polygon"][[1, 1]]]];
  df = RegionDistance[dhub];

  dists = Min[df /@ #[[1, 1]]]& /@ polygons;

  Select[Transpose[{cands, dists}], Last[#] < threshold&][[All, 1]]
]

ny = Entity["AdministrativeDivision", {"NewYork", "UnitedStates"}];
pa = Entity["AdministrativeDivision", {"Pennsylvania", "UnitedStates"}];

adminDivsPa = GeoEntities[pa, "USCounty"];

BorderingGeoEntities[adminDivsPa, ny] // AbsoluteTiming

enter image description here

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.