In delving into Ramanujan summation, I'm trying to get a hold of the relations of the form

$$\sum_{n=0}^\infty f(n)=\dfrac{h\frac{d}{dx}}{{\mathrm{e}^{h\frac{d}{dx}}}-1}\int_{0}^\infty f(x)\,{\mathrm{d}x}.$$

To express the right hand side in Mathematica, I might introduce an auxillary parameter in place of $\frac{d}{dx}$ and then do pattern to find the powers $\frac{d^k}{dx^k}f(x)$.

But it appears to me that I can actually avoid the shift operation $\mathrm{e}^{h\frac{d}{dx}}$ by expanding the quotient of infinitesimal vs. finite difference and do pattern matching for the result. So I'd like to the result of

Df = f'[x];
Dhf = (f[x + h] - f[x])/h;

Series[-Df/Dhf, {h, 0, 3}]

and replace each factor of $\dfrac{\prod_i f^{(a_i)}(x)^{b_i}}{f'(x)^c}$ with $\left(\frac{d}{dx}\right)^{\sum_ia_i\cdot b_i-c-1}$. For example,

  • The expression in the first coefficient $\dfrac{f^{(2)}(x)^1}{f'(x)^1}$ becomes $f^{(2\cdot 1-1-1)}(x)=f(x)$.

  • The expression $\dfrac{f'(x)\,f^{(3)}(x)}{f'(x)^2}$, which is part of the second coefficient becomes $f^{(1\cdot 1+3\cdot 1-2-1)}(x)=f'(x)$.

What happens is that the individual $f$-fraction in the term coefficient of $h^n$ are substituted with $f^{(n-1)}$. But it's relevant to keep all right the numerical coeffients, $\frac{1}{2}, -\frac{1}{12}$, etc.

(In the end I want to plug in $f(n):=n$, remove the leading coeffient by adding $1$ to the expression, evaluate at $n=0$ and obtain $1+2+3+\dots=-\frac{1}{12}$.)

I'm experimenting with the replace function, but I'm getting Tag-messages and I'm not sure if I need to order the terms for Mathematica to see what I want. How do I perform the above replacement of terms? This is the technique I want to learn here.

What I do can do is use


and obtain

 (1 - Series[f[x + h] - f[x], {h, 0, 3}]/h)^k,
 {k, 0, 2}]

 % /. {D[f[x], {x, n_}] -> 1}

but this is only an approximation and the expansion mixes up the orders of differentiation.


1 Answer 1


This might be along the lines of what you want. I expand the terms before trying the replacement, and do that in two steps so I don't have to deal separately with all manner of products.

Df = f'[x];
Dhf = (f[x + h] - f[x])/h;
ss = Expand[Normal[Series[-Df/Dhf, {h, 0, 3}]]]

(* Out[79]= -1 + (h*Derivative[2][f][x])/(2*Derivative[1][f][x]) - 
   (h^2*Derivative[2][f][x]^2)/(4*Derivative[1][f][x]^2) + 
   (h^3*Derivative[2][f][x]^3)/(8*Derivative[1][f][x]^3) + 
   (h^2*Derivative[3][f][x])/(6*Derivative[1][f][x]) - 
     (6*Derivative[1][f][x]^2) + (h^3*Derivative[4][f][x])/
     (24*Derivative[1][f][x]) *)
ss /. Derivative[n1_][f][x]^(e1_.) :> ddx^n1*e1 /. 
   ddx^(n_.) :> D[f[x], {x, n - 1}]

(* Out[83]= -1 - (1/2)*h*Derivative[2][f][x] + 
 h^2*Derivative[2][f][x] - 
   (9/8)*h^3*Derivative[2][f][x] - (1/6)*h^2*Derivative[3][f][x] - 
   (1/24)*h^3*Derivative[4][f][x] + (1/3)*h^3*Derivative[5][f][x] *)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.