If you dig in the default stylesheet belonging to your notebook the definition of the DisplayFormula style form which the DisplayFormula is derived. On my WIndows 8 PC it looks like this:
Cell[StyleData["DisplayFormula"],
CellMargins->{{66, Inherited}, {Inherited, Inherited}},
StripStyleOnPaste->True,
DefaultFormatType->DefaultInputFormatType,
HyphenationOptions->{"HyphenationCharacter"->"\[Continuation]"},
LanguageCategory->"Formula",
ScriptLevel->0,
SingleLetterItalics->True,
MenuSortingValue->1700,
FontFamily->"Arial",
FontSize->14,
FontColor->GrayLevel[0.2],
UnderoverscriptBoxOptions->{LimitsPositioning->True}]
You can see that the base font type is Arial. However you also see the line
DefaultFormatType->DefaultInputFormatType
which seems to indicate the default display type is InputForm
. This usually formats in a monospaced font such as Courier. Your formula will therefore look like this:

What you can do is change the format type to TraditionalForm
. You can do that by selecting the Cell>Convert to>TraditionalForm Display
menu item. Now your formula looks like this:

Checking the font using the Format menu confirms that this is indeed Arial as demanded in the stylesheet.
This is still different from a TraditionalForm
formatted code input which looks like this:

According to the font dialog this is indeed Times New Roman.
You can achieve this by copying the DisplayFormula and DisplayFormulaNumbered style definitions from the Default.nb parent of the private stylesheet of your notebook to this private stylesheet and opening the DisplayFormula definition using Cell>Show Expression (Ctrl+Shift+E) and changing the above line to read
FontFamily->"Times New Roman"
Your formula now looks like this (in TraditionalForm
display):

This is pretty close. You probably need to copy some definitions from the TraditionalForm
definition into the DisplayFormula definition to make it a perfect match.
Default.nb
of Mathematica $\endgroup$