How to make a function with its own options as well as passing options to other functions [duplicate]

Question

I have a function with many of its own options, but I would also like to pass options to subfunctions using the FilterRules function. Here's a simple example:

Options[pfunc] = {"test" -> True};
pfunc[x0_, plotopts : OptionsPattern[]] := Module[{},
  Plot[x^2, {x, -x0, x0}, 
   PlotStyle -> If[OptionValue["test"], Red, Blue], 
   Evaluate[FilterRules[{plotopts}, Options[Plot]]]]]

When I just try to use the options of the pfunc it works just fine

pfunc[7]
pfunc[7, "test" -> False]

But if I try to use an internal argument for Plot, it produces the figure as expected but gives error messages.

pfunc[7, "test" -> False, Frame -> True, Axes -> False]
(*
OptionValue::nodef: Unknown option Frame for pfunc. >>

OptionValue::nodef: Unknown option Axes for pfunc. >>

OptionValue::nodef: Unknown option BaseStyle for pfunc. >>

General::stop: Further output of OptionValue::nodef will be suppressed during this calculation. >>
*)

Why does it give these errors? Furthermore, what if I need to pass options to different subfunctions?

Answer 1

I don't know why no one mentioned this, but all you have to do is to use a special form of OptionsPattern:

pfunc[x0_, plotopts : OptionsPattern[{Plot, pfunc}]] := your-code

where inside OptionsPattern go all sub-functions you need, in a list. Now everything is fine and dandy.

This has been explained already in this answer of Mr. Wizard, so this answer and the whole question should be considered a duplicate.

There might be a downside of this, in case when several sub-functions can take the same subset of options, while you might want to pass some of the options to some sub-functions but not the other - in which case the special "PlotOptions" option, as suggested by rm -rf, might be a better solution. In the simple cases, however, OptionsPattern[{f1,f2,...}] is IMO the way to go.

Answer 2

It gives those errors because you explicitly specified that pfunc only has "test" as an option. OptionValue is finicky and will complain if it sees options that it doesn't recognize. There are a couple of alternatives that I can think of:

1: Use FilterRules everywhere instead of OptionValue

ClearAll@pfunc2
pfunc2[x0_, plotopts : OptionsPattern[]] := 
    Module[{test = If[FilterRules[{plotopts}, "test"] === {}, True]},
        Plot[x^2, {x, -x0, x0}, PlotStyle -> If[test, Red, Blue], 
            Evaluate[FilterRules[{plotopts}, Options[Plot]]]
        ]
    ]

The downside of this is that you have to pass the plotopts argument every time. You can fix this somewhat by defining some kind of local function as optval = FilterRules[{plotopts}, #]& and use that like OptionValue. However, by not explicitly specifying the options that your function takes, you make it harder for someone to get a summary of the function's usage by using ?.

2. Use a separate option to pass all options to Plot

I prefer this approach which is more verbose, but clear in intent:

ClearAll@pfunc3
Options@pfunc3 = {"test" -> True, "PlotOptions" -> {}};
pfunc3[x0_, plotopts : OptionsPattern[]] := Module[{},
  Plot[x^2, {x, -x0, x0}, 
   PlotStyle -> If[OptionValue["test"], Red, Blue], 
   Evaluate@OptionValue["PlotOptions"]]]

You can add additional checks to make sure that only valid options are being passed to Plot, but you get the idea. The added advantage is that this is easily extendable to more complex scenarios. For instance, suppose you have a type of plot that has a grid of Plot, Graphics and a DensityPlot. What do you do with the first approach if you want to pass different options to each of those? It's not going to be easy, since they all accept Frame, PlotStyle, Mesh etc. With this approach, you can group the options as "PlotOptions" -> {...}, "DensityPlotOptions" -> {...}, "GraphicsOptions" -> {...} and so on.

Answer 3

I believe you need to add all of Plot's options to pfunc as well, like this:

Options[pfunc] = Join[ Options[Plot], {"test" -> True, ...} ]

I'd like to note that this is what builtins do as well. For example, Plot also carries all possible Graphics options. The downside is that any changes to the default options of Plot won't affect pfunc. The upside is that it will be possible to change the defaults on pfunc, and also that you get error reporting about invalid options for free.

There are some other things worth correcting: while Plot and Graphics accept options grouped into a list, as in Plot[..., {Frame -> True, PlotStyle -> Red}], many other functions don't.

So I'd write the function like this:

pfunc[x0_, plotopts : OptionsPattern[]] := 
 With[{seq = Sequence @@ FilterRules[{plotopts}, Options[Plot]]},
  Plot[x^2, {x, -x0, x0}, seq, PlotStyle -> If[OptionValue["test"], Red, Blue]]
 ]

I also moved seq before your own PlotStyle option, to make the PlotStyle overridable.

Well, this is how I usually do it, but since I don't have a lot of experience with options handling, I'm not sure it's the best way.

Answer 4

I have found a workaround, but I don't think it's the most elegant solution available. Basically, I separate the Plot options from the pfunc options via curly brackets, like this:

Options[pfunc] = {"test" -> True};
pfunc[{x0_, plotopts : OptionsPattern[]}, OptionsPattern[]] := 
 Module[{},
  Plot[x^2, {x, -x0, x0}, 
   PlotStyle -> If[OptionValue["test"], Red, Blue], 
   Evaluate[FilterRules[{plotopts}, Options[Plot]]]]]
pfunc[{7, Frame -> True, Axes -> False, BaseStyle -> 20}, 
 "test" -> False]

This produces the same plot as above without any error messages.

This is a fine workaround, but sometimes you want to pass options to different subfunctions. This is what I've been able to come up with, but it feels like there should be a better way:

Options[pfunc2] = {"test" -> True};
pfunc2[{x0_, 
   plotopts : OptionsPattern[]}, {plotopts2 : OptionsPattern[]}, 
  OptionsPattern[]] := Module[{p1, p2},
  p1 = Plot[x^2, {x, -x0, x0}, 
    PlotStyle -> If[OptionValue["test"], Red, Blue], 
    Evaluate[FilterRules[{plotopts}, Options[Plot]]]];
  p2 = Plot[x^3, {x, -x0, x0}, 
    PlotStyle -> If[OptionValue["test"], Red, Blue], 
    Evaluate[FilterRules[{plotopts2}, Options[Plot]]]];
  Grid[{{p1, p2}}]]


pfunc[{7, Frame -> True, Axes -> False, 
  BaseStyle -> 20}, {Axes -> False, Frame -> True, ImageSize -> 300}]

pfunc2[{7, Frame -> True, Axes -> False, BaseStyle -> 20}, {}, 
 "test" -> False]

And then if you don't want to pass any options you do it like this:

pfunc2[{7}, {}]