With Block or Module we can specify variables local to their scope in curly brackets like this:


How can we do the same with compiled functions? The manual states that

Compiled code does not handle numerical precision and local variables in the same way as ordinary Wolfram Language code.

but there does not seem to be an example on how to define a local variable within the scope of a compiled function. How would a trivial minimal example look like?

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ You simply can use Block or Module in the body of the compiled function. It does not matter; both ways just tell Compile to make the variables local. $\endgroup$ – Henrik Schumacher Feb 7 '18 at 7:50

What configuration one chooses depends on the specific needs of the function one is compiling and other general considerations about the relative place and function of that piece of code in the rest of one's script/program.

With that in mind, one way to achieve what is being asked is to use With; this way, one can incorporate simple constants in a compiled function, eg

(* a compiled function with a constant *)
f = With[{alpha=3.507}, 
   Compile[{{x,_Real}}, 2*alpha-x*1.09]

The approach presented above addresses the need to use "constants* inside the compiled function; local variables that can take on different values during the lifespan of the local scope need to be introduced in a different way.

f = Compile[{{x,_Real}}, Module[{y=x+3.},

This last example, contrived as it might be, introduces the use of local variables inside a compiled function with the help of Module.

The first answer to this question, has a lot of packed information on the use of Compile; there are also examples of uses with compilation that uses local variables.

Also, as a side-note, the first answer to this question demonstrates the various scoping structures available in Mathematica. I include this last link, although it is not directly related to compilation, because the question involves the use of Block; I have refrained from using it in this answer, as the linked response suggests that it should be used in those cases it is absolutely necessasary to, otherwise Module will suffice.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.