Return to Answer

Consider this:

Inactivate[3*5 - 2 - 3] // FullForm

Inactive[Plus][Inactive[Times][3, 5], -2, -3]

RunnyKine is correct regarding the cause but he did not really explain the mechanism involved. Formatting rules typically apply to (sub)expressions with certain heads. This has nothing to do with evaluation per se, but rather the patterns in the transformation rules of MakeBoxes.

In this example the formatting rules for Times are still applied despite HoldComplete:

HoldComplete[Times[x, y]] // TraditionalForm

HoldComplete[x y]

Another example and further explanation can be seen in my answer to:

• Returning an unevaluated expression with values substituted in

Simply put Inactive[Times] does not match the patterns used by MakeBoxes for pretty formatting. However we can easily add our own rules. If you wish to have expressions produced by Inactivate formatted as the normal form of the expression (without evaluation) you may use:

MakeBoxes[p : Inactive[h_][args___], form_] := 
  MakeBoxes[Interpretation[HoldForm @ h[args], p], form]

Now the expression is formatted using the normal rules for Times and Plus:

Without the definition this is printed without the nice formatting:

Consider this:

Inactivate[3*5 - 2 - 3] // FullForm

Inactive[Plus][Inactive[Times][3, 5], -2, -3]

RunnyKine is correct regarding the cause but he did not really explain the mechanism involved. Formatting rules typically apply to (sub)expressions with certain heads. This has nothing to do with evaluation per se, but rather the patterns in the transformation rules of MakeBoxes.

In this example the formatting rules for Times are still applied despite HoldComplete:

HoldComplete[Times[x, y]] // TraditionalForm

HoldComplete[x y]

Another example and further explanation can be seen in my answer to:

• Returning an unevaluated expression with values substituted in

Simply put Inactive[Times] does not match the patterns used by MakeBoxes for pretty formatting. However we can easily add our own rules. If you wish to have expressions produced by Inactivate formatted as the normal form of the expression (without evaluation) you may use:

MakeBoxes[p : Inactive[h_][args___], form_] := 
  MakeBoxes[Interpretation[HoldForm @ h[args], p], form]

Now the expression is formatted using the normal rules for Times and Plus:

Without the definition this is printed without the nice formatting:

Consider this:

Inactivate[3*5 - 2 - 3] // FullForm

Inactive[Plus][Inactive[Times][3, 5], -2, -3]

RunnyKine is correct regarding the cause but he did not really explain the mechanism involved. Formatting rules typically apply to expressions with certain heads. This has nothing to do with evaluation per se, but rather the patterns in the rules of MakeBoxes.

In this example the formatting rules for Times are still applied despite HoldComplete:

HoldComplete[Times[x, y]] // TraditionalForm

HoldComplete[x y]

Another example and further explanation can be seen in my answer to:

• Returning an unevaluated expression with values substituted in

Simply put Inactive[Times] does not match the patterns used by MakeBoxes for pretty formatting. However we can easily add our own rules. If you wish to have expressions produced by Inactivate formatted as the normal form of the expression (without evaluation) you may use:

MakeBoxes[p : Inactive[h_][args___], form_] := 
  MakeBoxes[Interpretation[HoldForm @ h[args], p], form]

Now the expression is formatted using the normal rules for Times and Plus:

Without the definition this is printed without the nice formatting:

Consider this:

Inactivate[3*5 - 2 - 3] // FullForm

Inactive[Plus][Inactive[Times][3, 5], -2, -3]

RunnyKine is correct regarding the cause but he did not really explain the mechanism involved. Formatting rules typically apply to (sub)expressions with certain heads. This has nothing to do with evaluation per se, but rather the patterns in the transformation rules of MakeBoxes.

In this example the formatting rules for Times are still applied despite HoldComplete:

HoldComplete[Times[x, y]] // TraditionalForm

HoldComplete[x y]

Another example and further explanation can be seen in my answer to:

• Returning an unevaluated expression with values substituted in

Simply put Inactive[Times] does not match the patterns used by MakeBoxes for pretty formatting. However we can easily add our own rules. If you wish to have expressions produced by Inactivate formatted as the normal form of the expression (without evaluation) you may use:

MakeBoxes[p : Inactive[h_][args___], form_] := 
  MakeBoxes[Interpretation[HoldForm @ h[args], p], form]

Now the expression is formatted using the normal rules for Times and Plus:

Without the definition this is printed without the nice formatting:

Consider this:

Inactivate[3*5 - 2 - 3] // FullForm

Inactive[Plus][Inactive[Times][3, 5], -2, -3]

RunnyKine is correct regarding the cause but he did not really explain the mechanism involved. Formatting rules are based on patterns that typically apply to expressions with certain heads. This has nothing to do with evaluation per se, but rather the patterns in the rules of MakeBoxes.

In this example the formatting rules for Times is still applied despite HoldComplete:

HoldComplete[Times[x, y]] // TraditionalForm

HoldComplete[x y]

Another example can be seen in my answer to:

• Returning an unevaluated expression with values substituted in

Simply put Inactive[Times] does not match the patterns used by MakeBoxes for pretty formatting. However we can easily add our own rules. If you wish to have expressions produced by Inactivate formatted as the normal form of the expression (without evaluation) you may use:

MakeBoxes[p : Inactive[h_][args___], form_] := 
  MakeBoxes[Interpretation[HoldForm @ h[args], p], form]

Now the expression is formatted using the normal rules for Times and Plus:

Without the definition this is printed without the nice formatting:

Consider this:

Inactivate[3*5 - 2 - 3] // FullForm

Inactive[Plus][Inactive[Times][3, 5], -2, -3]

RunnyKine is correct regarding the cause but he did not really explain the mechanism involved. Formatting rules typically apply to expressions with certain heads. This has nothing to do with evaluation per se, but rather the patterns in the rules of MakeBoxes.

In this example the formatting rules for Times are still applied despite HoldComplete:

HoldComplete[Times[x, y]] // TraditionalForm

HoldComplete[x y]

Another example and further explanation can be seen in my answer to:

• Returning an unevaluated expression with values substituted in

Simply put Inactive[Times] does not match the patterns used by MakeBoxes for pretty formatting. However we can easily add our own rules. If you wish to have expressions produced by Inactivate formatted as the normal form of the expression (without evaluation) you may use:

MakeBoxes[p : Inactive[h_][args___], form_] := 
  MakeBoxes[Interpretation[HoldForm @ h[args], p], form]

Now the expression is formatted using the normal rules for Times and Plus:

Without the definition this is printed without the nice formatting: