How to delete elements from list1 appearing in list2?

Question

I'm new to functional programming of Mathematica and trying to remove one list of assorted elements from another. However I only find functions working with the Index rather than the values itself:

 list1={b,a,e,f,c,d}  
 list2={f,e,c}

I can now remove list2 from list1:

 result={b,a,d}  

I already found out, that you can "abuse"

DeleteCases[list1, a] 

to remove 1 specific element from a list, but not a whole assorted list...

I would be very grateful for a simple solution to do it.
Thanks a lot for any answer!

Answer 1

Use

DeleteCases[list1, Alternatives @@ list2]

In new versions (M8.0+), DeleteCases is optimized on patterns not involving blanks, so this will be fast also for large lists. For earlier versions, this will work:

Replace[list1, Dispatch[Thread[list2 -> Sequence[]]],{1}]

being 2-3 times slower, but still very fast.

Answer 2

You are perhaps searching for Complement. Complement[list1, list2] results in {a, b, d}. The result is sorted though. If you are looking for an unsorted complement, DeleteCases[list1, Alternatives @@ list2] should probably work. I think there are some discussions on unsorted complements out there at google.

Answer 3

Iff each list is internally free of duplicates you can use this very quick method:

DeleteDuplicates[#2 ~Join~ #] ~Drop~ Length[#2] &[list1, list2]

Answer 4

Since Yves beat me narrowly to my first solution, here's another one using Select:

Select[list1, FreeQ[list2, #] &]
Out[2]= {b, a, d}

This does not sort your result.

---

You can also use Complement, which is more intuitive. Example:

Complement[list1, list2]
Out[1]= {a, b, d}

Note that this sorts your result (i.e., it is not in the same order, {b, a, d}).

Answer 5

Unsorted Complement. I think it originates from MathGroup. It accepts the SameTest option.

Options[UnsortedComplement] = {SameTest -> Automatic};
UnsortedComplement[all_, del___, opts : OptionsPattern[]] := 
  Replace[all, 
   List @@ (Rule[#, Sequence[]] & /@ Union[del, opts]), {1}];

all = RandomInteger[{0, 9}, {20}]
UnsortedComplement[all, {6, 2, 8}, {2, 3, 4}]

(*
  ==> {8, 4, 2, 5, 8, 8, 6, 6, 2, 1, 3, 1, 1, 2, 8, 0, 5, 5, 8, 1}

  ==> {5, 1, 1, 1, 0, 5, 5, 1}
*)

It also works with any head, not just List-s.

Answer 6

Just nest it:

Fold[DeleteCases[#1, #2] &, list1, list2]

Answer 7

I hesitate to add to this old discussion after these excellent answers and other essential reading especially here, but this amalgamation of many suggestions may be of interest. cutEverything[xx_, removeList__] removes all entries of all elements of removeList_ from xx_ regardless of their depth or whether they are duplicates. It leaves compounds in place and does not change the original list order.

x = 
  {pudepied, pudepied.txt, {pudepied}, {{{pudepied}}, {zap}, {{peter}}}, {{pudepied}}, 
   blah, zap, "Wolfram Language", {peter}, {{{}}}, mary, {{{{mary}}}}};

remove = {pudepied, peter, mary, {}};
cutEverything[xx_, removeList_] := 
  Replace[xx, x_List :> DeleteCases[x, Alternatives @@ removeList], {0, Infinity}]
cutEverything[x, remove]

 {pudepied.txt, {{zap}}, blah, zap, Wolfram Language}

Answer 8

DeleteElements[{b, a, e, f, c, d}, \[Infinity] \[Rule] {f, e, c}]

    (*{b, a, d}*)

Unfortunately, the new function DeleteElements is not faster:

In[1]:= list1 = RandomReal[1, 2*^4]; list2 = 
         Catenate[{RandomChoice[list1, 6*^3], RandomReal[1, 4*^3]}];

In[2]:= result0=DeleteElements[list1,list2];//AbsoluteTiming

Out[2]= {3.78426, Null}

In[3]:= result1=DeleteCases[list1,Alternatives@@list2];//AbsoluteTiming

Out[3]= {0.01786, Null}

In[4]:= result2=Replace[list1,Dispatch[Thread[list2->Sequence[]]],{1}];//AbsoluteTiming

Out[4]= {0.0342811, Null}

In[5]:= result3=Replace[list1,x_List:>DeleteCases[x,Alternatives@@list2],{0,Infinity}];//AbsoluteTiming

Out[5]= {0.0222806, Null}

In[6]:= result4=Fold[DeleteCases[##]&,list1,list2];//AbsoluteTiming

Out[6]= {24.3309, Null}

In[7]:= Equal[result0,result1,result2,result3,result4]

Out[7]= True

Other ways are much slower, so I omit them here.

Answer 9

To explore the preceding answer a little bit further:

list1 = {b, a, e, f, c, d};
list2 = {f, e, c};

DeleteElements[list1, list2]

{b, a, d}

If list1 contains duplicated elements:

list1 = {b, a, e, f, c, c, d};
list2 = {f, e, c};

Delete all elements:

DeleteElements[list1, list2]

{b, a, d}

Delete up to 1 element:

DeleteElements[list1, 1 -> list2]

{b, a, c, d}

Answer 10

Using Cases:

list1 = {b, a, e, f, c, d};
list2 = {f, e, c};

Cases[list1, x_ /; FreeQ[x, Alternatives @@ list2] :> x]

{b, a, d}