Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematica Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for users of Mathematica. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I am trying to solve the following non-linear equation:

$\frac{i e^{-x^2} \sqrt{\pi } x}{K^2}+\left(-0.131251-0.0379031 x^2-0.0151154 x^4-0.0100462 x^6+0.5 \left(0.00273859 +0.0400003 K^2\right) x^8+(0. +0.0000362178 i) x^9+0.5 \left(\text{6.72230790401107$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-6}+0.000122761 K^2\right) x^{10}+(0. +\text{7.371834962565406$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-8} i) x^{11}+0.5 \left(\text{3.049800199384706$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-9}+\text{7.195529551699709$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-8} K^2\right) x^{12}+(0. +\text{3.611964212904051$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-11} i) x^{13}+0.5 \left(-\text{1.2612171276659422$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-12}-\text{1.7472476684229308$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-11} K^2\right) x^{14}+\text{2.7423509229173302$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-15} K^2 x^{16}\right)/\left(0.0200001 K^2 x^8+0.0000613803 K^2 x^{10}+\text{3.5977647758498545$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-8} K^2 x^{12}-\text{8.736238342114654$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-12} K^2 x^{14}+\text{2.7423509229173302$\grave{ }$*${}^{\wedge}$-15} K^2 x^{16}\right)$

Here's the Mathematica code I used:

Solve[(I E^-x^2 Sqrt[\[Pi]] x)/
    k^2 + (-0.13125090233975123 - 0.037903065816010294 x^2 - 
      0.015115427229185784 x^4 - 0.010046171350985062 x^6 + 
      0.5 (0.0027385850487922922 + 
         0.04000027499878133 k^2) x^8 + (0. + 
         0.000036217780642055754 I) x^9 + 
      0.5 (6.72230790401107*10^-6 + 
         0.00012276053475132815 k^2) x^10 + (0. + 
         7.371834962565406*10^-8 I) x^11 + 
      0.5 (3.049800199384706*10^-9 + 
         7.195529551699709*10^-8 k^2) x^12 + (0. + 
         3.611964212904051*10^-11 I) x^13 + 
      0.5 (-1.2612171276659422*10^-12 - 
         1.7472476684229308*10^-11 k^2) x^14 + 
      2.7423509229173302*10^-15 k^2 x^16)/(0.020000137499390665 k^2 x^8 + 
         0.00006138026737566407 k^2 x^10 + 
      3.5977647758498545*10^-8 k^2 x^12 - 
      8.736238342114654*10^-12 k^2 x^14 + 
      2.7423509229173302*10^-15 k^2 x^16) == 0, x]

where x is a complex variable and k is a real one.

I get this error message:

Solve::nsmet : This system cannot be solved with the methods available to Solve. >>

Please, I need to find x in terms of k and plot the output x versus k.

How can I use Mathematica techniques to solve this equation?

share|improve this question
Ummm…are you looking for a symbolic solution in terms of the unknowns or a numerical solution (in which case you need to provide values for the a, b, c…). Regardless, what makes you think there is a solution? –  Cassini Apr 25 '14 at 19:31
Also, K is a system symbol so don't use it. The black colouring warns you about this. –  Szabolcs Apr 25 '14 at 19:36
I should leave this to the mathematicians, but I seriously doubt you're going to find a symbolic solution. If you want a numeric solution, you need to specify the values of a, b, c... –  Cassini Apr 25 '14 at 19:48
I'm afraid this type of question is not a Mathematica question. It is a math question. It sounds like you just want a solution to the equation. Asking to do it using Mathematica doens't automatically make it a Mathematica question. Adding "...using Mathematica" cannot be used as an excuse to ask anything here... First you need to make it clear (to yourself and to us) that it is at all reasonable to expect that there is a simple symbolic solution. If you need a numeric solution then rephrase your question to make that clear and provide sufficient information (values of parameters). –  Szabolcs Apr 25 '14 at 20:01
This question appears to be off-topic because it is too localized; i.e, it applies only to the local situation and needs of its poster and answers will not benefit others. –  m_goldberg Apr 26 '14 at 5:27

1 Answer 1

I believe the OP's equation has infinitely many solutions x for a given k. That might pose some difficulty. It does for giving a definitive answer.

From Plotting implicitly-defined space curves, you can find ways to plot the solutions. The method below follows this answer by Szabolcs. The way that the linked question applies to the OP's case is this: The complex equation eqn == 0 corresponds to two real equations Re@eqn == Im@eqn == 0; further, if we write x = re + im I in terms of its real and imaginary parts, we turn the equation into a pair equations in terms of three real variables {re, im, k}.

The variable eqn represents the left-hand side of the OP's equation. I got rid of the denominators (eqn1) because they led to divide-by-zero errors that broke lines.

Clear[re, im, x];
eqn1 = Numerator @ Simplify[Expand @ First @ eqn] == 0;
mfRe = Function[{re, im, k},  Re @ First @ eqn1 /. x -> re + im I // Evaluate ];

plot = ContourPlot3D[
 0 == Im@First@eqn1 /. x -> re + im I // Evaluate,
 {re, -3, 3}, {im, -3, 3}, {k, -1, 1},
 Mesh -> {{0}}, MeshFunctions -> {mfRe},
 ContourStyle -> None, BoundaryStyle -> None, AxesLabel -> Automatic,
 MeshStyle -> {Red, Thick}]

Mathematica graphics

Some of the lines look broken. One could increase PlotPoints or MaxRecursion to see if ContourPlot can connect them up.

We can extract the lines and convert them to solutions, somewhat like this answer to Getting an InterpolatingFunction from a ContourPlot:

sols = With[{pts = First@Cases[plot, GraphicsComplex[pp_, ___] :> pp, Infinity]},
   pts[[#]] & /@ Cases[plot, Line[p_] :> p, Infinity]

We'll see which curve is the first Line in the plot:

With[{line1 = First[sols]},
  sol1 = Interpolation[
    Transpose@{line1[[All, 3]], line1[[All, {1, 2}]]}]

ParametricPlot3D[Join[sol1[k], {k}], 
 Evaluate[Prepend[First@sol1["Domain"], k]], 
 PlotRange -> {{-3, 3}, {-3, 3}, {-1, 1}}, BoxRatios -> {1, 1, 1}, 
 AxesLabel -> {re, im, k}] 

Mathematica graphics

The function sol1 represents an approximate solution, but not a very good one (for an exact answer, First@eqn would evaluate to zero):

sol1[0.5].{1, I}
First@eqn /. {x -> sol1[0.5].{1, I}, k -> 0.5}
(* 1.30297 - 0.652346 I *)
(* -0.00599196 - 0.00566206 I *)

If a more accurate result is desired, one may apply FindRoot to each point:

With[{line1 = First[sols]},
  sol2 = Interpolation[
    {#[[3]], x /. FindRoot[
         First@eqn1 /. k -> #[[3]], {x, #[[{1, 2}]].{1, I}}]} & /@ line1]

First@eqn /. {x -> sol2[0.5], k -> 0.5}
(* -8.76055*10^-12 + 6.38489*10^-13 I *)
share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.