Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematica Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for users of Mathematica. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Recently in response to this question Mr.Wizard suggested an unusual way to summing numbers. This doesn't seem to be documented.

HoldForm[+##] & @@ RandomInteger[100, 2]

This works fine for Plus and in case of - it generates -ive of product of list elements. I could not find out how to write a close variation of this for Divide or Subtract or other operations.

Can someone please shed some light on this ?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

up vote 4 down vote accepted

From prior comments I know that you are interested in forms such as:

a - b - c - d
a / b / c / d

There is no simple short form for these as there is for Plus. To understand this you must understand how Mathematica parses and displays these expressions. Let's look at the first one:

Subtract

HoldForm[a - b - c - d]
a - b - c - d

No surprises. But now FullForm:

HoldForm @ FullForm[a - b - c - d]
Plus[a, Times[-1, b], Times[-1, c], Times[-1, d]]

So our simple expression is not quite so simple in the internal format. Each negative term is actually represented as Times[-1, x]. But what about Box form? This is what is sent to the Front End for display:

HoldForm[a - b - c - d] // ToBoxes
TagBox[RowBox[{"a", "-", "b", "-", "c", "-", "d"}], HoldForm]

We will need a helper utility(1) to see what the Front End sends to the Kernel:

parseString[s_String, prep : (True | False) : True] := 
  FrontEndExecute[UndocumentedTestFEParserPacket[s, prep]]

Now:

"a-b-c-d" // parseString
{BoxData[RowBox[{"a", "-", "b", "-", "c", "-", "d"}]], StandardForm}

Divide

The same analysis of the division/fraction case:

HoldForm[a/b/c/d]
a/((b c) d)

This time you may get a bit of a surprise. Let's look at the FullForm:

HoldForm @ FullForm[a/b/c/d]
Times[Times[Times[a, Power[b, -1]], Power[c, -1]], Power[d, -1]]

Once again we see that there is no "division" operator, but rather denominators are represented as Power[x, -1]. Why though is this displayed as a/((b c) d)? Let's look at the box form sent to the Front End:

HoldForm[a/b/c/d] // ToBoxes
TagBox[FractionBox["a", 
  RowBox[{RowBox[{"(", RowBox[{"b", " ", "c"}], ")"}], " ", "d"}]], HoldForm]

So our Times/Power expression is converted to this different format during Box conversion even though the internal format contains no "fraction" head. This alternative Box form creation is not prevent by Hold function. See Returning an unevaluated expression with values substituted in for another example of this.

What about the input format however? Clearly a/b/c/d can be displayed by the Front End as you can simply type that in. What is its Box form?

"a/b/c/d" // parseString
{BoxData[RowBox[{RowBox[{RowBox[{"a", "/", "b"}], "/", "c"}], "/", "d"}]], StandardForm}

Input Syntax

By now you are probably I understanding what I meant when I said "it's complicated." You may also see that there is a difference between inputting the equivalent expression, which may be displayed differently, e.g. a/((b c) d), and having Mathematica display a certain form such as a/b/c/d. We can explore both.

Taking things in reverse order, we can use Row to merely display an expression:

Row[{a, b, c, d}, "-"]
Row[{a, b, c, d}, "/"]
a-b-c-d

a/b/c/d

This is not meaningful mathematical input. It is only a display form. Also it is not "intelligent" about mathematical formatting such as negatives:

Row[{a, -b, c, d}, "-"]  (* note -b *)
a--b-c-d

This was the motivation for using e.g. HoldForm[+##] rather than Row in the first place: we wanted the automatic formatting, just not the automatic evaluation.

If you desire a shorthand for entering a valid mathematical expression you could negate after in the case of subtraction:

-+## &[a, -b, c, d]
-a + b - c - d

You'll note this also negates the first term. It isn't clear to me if you want this or not; you could use # - +##2 & if you do not.

For formatting purposes this won't work:

HoldForm[-+##] &[1, -2, 3, 4]
-(1 - 2 + 3 + 4)

You would instead need to negate the terms first:

HoldForm[+##] & @@ -{##} &[1, -2, 3, 4]
-1 + 2 - 3 - 4

Division will not display as a/b/c/d anyway, as already demonstrated, so you are probably better off using Row for that display format. (Or building Box form directly, though I'd rather not make this answer any longer to show how.) For inputting a valid mathematical expression you could use:

#/(1 ##2) &[a, b, c, d]
a/(b c d)
share|improve this answer

This works fine:

HoldForm[Divide@##] & @@ RandomInteger[100, 2]
share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.