Mathematica Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for users of Mathematica. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I want to define a function which takes in two integers (indicating the lengths of 2 vectors), and solves a simple set of expressions at a set of points to find all the values in both the vectors.

so far I have managed to successfully create a function which does exactly what I say above, except that rather than taking two integers as arguments, it takes the two vectors itself. Forgive me for the length of this next code fragment:

solution[svec_, nvec_] := 
     approx[svec, nvec, -Cos[n*Pi/(Length[nvec] + Length[svec])]] == 
       exact[-Cos[n*Pi/(Length[nvec] + Length[svec])]],
     {n, 1, Length[nvec] + Length[svec]}],
   Join[svec, nvec]];


-Cos[n*Pi/(Length[nvec] + Length[svec])

part is just a set of points. All of the above works fine.

My attempt to change it so that it takes in just integers was to do the following:

STEP ONE: create a function which takes an integer, gives a vector of length integer:

nvec[Q_] := Table[Unique["n"], {Q}];
svec[M_] := Table[Unique["s"], {M}];

STEP TWO: replace all of the svecs and nvecs in the previous code fragment with nvec[Q] and svec[M]. (could also get rid of Lengths obviously):

solution[Q_, M_] := 
      approx[svec[M], nvec[Q], -Cos[n*Pi/(Q + M)]] == exact[-Cos[n*Pi/(Q + M)]],
      {n, 1, M + Q}],
    Join[svec[M], nvec[Q]]];

STEP THREE: Call the function

sol = solution[10, 20]

For some reason, this doesn't work. I never get an error; it just never finishes evaluating. Any help would be very much appreciated

share|improve this question
Does it work if you replace your solution[Q_,M_] by solution2[Q_, M_] := With[{sv = svec[M], nv = nvec[Q]}, NSolve[Table[ approx[sv, nv, -Cos[n*Pi/(Q + M)]] == exact[-Cos[n*Pi/(Q + M)]], {n, 1, M + Q}], Join[sv, nv]]]? – kglr Mar 4 '13 at 16:43
yes! Thank you very much, i'll have to look up why that works :) – user5866 Mar 4 '13 at 16:54
btw, using this method is there a simple way to get out the vectors being solved? for example I used to use sing = 1.0*svec /. sol – user5866 Mar 4 '13 at 16:58

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.